Sederi Yearbook 25

Sederi 25
Sederi 25 — 2015
Berta Cano Echevarría & Ana Sáez-Hidalgo
Francisco J. Borge López
ISSN 1135-7789


Victor Houliston, “Filling in the Blanks: Catholic Hopes for the English Succession.” SEDERI 25 (2015): 77-104.


DOI:                                                     Download PDF



English Catholics, both at home and abroad, were faced with difficult choices as the question of the succession became increasingly acute in the last decade of Elizabeth’s reign. In an attempt to analyse the complexity of Catholic expectations and manoeuvres, this article examines the actions and writings of three prominent figures: the courtier-poet and recent convert Henry Constable, the Jesuit leader Robert Persons, and the layman Sir Thomas Tresham. Their relations with King James VI of Scotland illustrate the precariousness of his position, and their interactions during this period of shifting allegiances call into question some received assumptions about the divisions within the English Catholic community. Close attention to their writing also reveals the significance of an appeal to a chivalric code of honour in these politico-religious negotiations.

Keywords: English succession; recusancy; Jesuits; chivalry; Henry Constable; Robert Persons; Sir Thomas Tresham; James VI and I; Philippe du Plessis-Mornay.




Akrigg, G. P. V. 1984. Letters of King James VI & I. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press.

Bagley, J. J. 1985. The Earls of Derby, 1485-1985. London: Sidgwick & Jackson.

Bell, Thomas 1603. The anatomie of popish tyrannie. London: I. Harrison for R. Bankworth.

Bossy, John 1961-1962. “A Propos of Henry Constable.” Recusant History 6: 228-37.

Bossy, John 1965-1966. “Henri IV, the Appellants and the Jesuits.” Recusant History 8: 80-122.

Brown, Rawdon, George Bentinck, Horatio F. Brown and A. B. Hinds, eds. 1864-1947. Calendar of State Papers and Manuscripts, Relating to English Affairs, Existing in the Archives and Collections of Venice, and in Other Libraries of Northern Italy. 38 vols in 40. London: Longman, Green & Co.

Bruce, John, ed. 1861. Correspondence of King James VI of Scotland with Sir Robert Cecil and Others in England, during the Reign of Queen Elizabeth. Camden Society 78. London: Camden Society.

Bruce, John ed. 1896. Diary of John Manningham, of the Middle Temple, and of Bradbourne, Kent, Barrister-at-Law, 1602-1603. Camden Society 99. London: J.B. Nichols & Sons.

Collinson, Patrick 2014. “Bishop Richard Bancroft and the Succession.” Eds. Susan Doran and Paulina Kewes. Doubtful and Dangerous: The Question of Succession in late Elizabethan England. Manchester: Manchester University Press: 92-111.

Constable, Henry 1589. Examen pacifique de la doctrine des Huguenots: Prouuant contre les Catholiques rigoureux de nostre temps & particulierement contre les obiections de la response faicte a l’Apologie Ctholique [sic], que nous qui sommes membres de l’Eglise Catholique Apostolique & Romaine ne deurions pas condemner les Huguenots pour heretiques iusques a ce qu’on ait faict nouuelle preuue. Paris, vere London: J. Wolfe.

Constable, Henry 1600. A discoverye of a counterfecte conference helde at a counterfecte place, by counterfecte travellers, for thadvancement of a conterfecte tytle, and invented, printed, and published by one (PERSON) that dare not avowe his name. Cologne, vere Paris: Charles Paget.

Constable, Henry 1623. The Catholic Moderator: or A moderate examination of the doctrine of the Protestants. Prouing against the too rigid Catholikes of these times, and against the arguments especially, of that booke called, The answer to the Catholike apologie, that we, who are members of the Catholike, apostolike, and Roman Church, ought not to condemne the Protestants for heretikes, vntill further proofe be made. Trans. W. W. London: Nathaniel Butter for Eliot’s Court Press.

Cooper, Elizabeth 1886. The Life and Letters of Lady Arabella Stuart. 2 vols. London: Hurst & Blackett.

CSPD > see Lemon and Green (1856-1872).

CSP Simancas > see Hume (1892-1899).

CSP Venetian > see Brown, Bentinck, Brown and Hinds (1864-1947).

Daussy, Hugues 2002. Les Huguenots et le roi: Le combat politique de Philippe Duplessis-Mornay (1572-1600). Geneva: Droz.

Doleman, R. 1595. A Conference about the Next Succession to the Crowne of Ingland > see Persons, R. (1595).

Doran, Susan and Paulina Kewes, eds. 2014. Doubtful and Dangerous: The Question of Succession in late Elizabethan England. Manchester: Manchester University Press.

Edwards, Francis 1995. Robert Persons: The Biography of an Elizabethan Jesuit, 1546-1610. St Louis: Institute of Jesuit Sources.

Foley, Henry 1875-1883. Records of the English Province of the Society of Jesus. 7 vols in 8. London: Burns & Oates.

Guilday, Peter 1914. The English Catholic Refugees on the Continent 1558-1795. Vol. 1. The English Colleges and Convents in the Catholic Low Countries, 1558-1795. London: Longmans, Green, & Co..

Hammer, Paul E.J. 1999. The Polarisation of Elizabethan Politics: The Political Career of Robert Devereus, 2nd Earl of Essex, 1585-1597. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Hicks, L. 1955. “Sir Robert Cecil, Father Persons and the Succession.” Archivum Historicum Societatis Iesu 24: 95-139.

Hicks, L.  1957-1958. “Father Robert Persons, S.J. and the Book of Succession.” Recusant History 4: 104-37.

HMC Hatfield House > see Roberts, Salisbury, Guiseppi and Owen (1883-1976).

HMC L’Isle > see Lethbridge, Shaw and Owen (1925-1966).

HMC Various Collections > see Lomas (1904).

Holmes, Peter 1980. “The Authorship and Early Reception of A Conference about the Next Succession to the Crown of England.” Historical Journal 23: 415-29.

Houliston, Victor 2000. “The Hare and the Drum: Robert Persons’s Writings on the English Succession, 1593-1596.” Renaissance Studies 14: 235-50.

Houliston, Victor 2008. “Shaming and Containing: Robert Persons Sets the Standards for Ecclesiastical Tournaments.” Southern African Journal of Medieval and Renaissance Studies 18: 89-120.

Hume, Martin A. S. 1892-1899. Calendar of Letters and Papers relating to English affairs preserved principally in the archives of Simancas. 4 vols. London: Eyre and Spottiswood for HM Stationery Office.

Hume, Martin A. S. 1901. Treason and Plot: Struggles for Catholic Supremacy in the Last Years of Queen Elizabeth. London: James Nisbet.

Jenkins, Gladys 1948. “The Archpriest Controversy and the Printers, 1601-1603.” The Library, 5th ser. 1: 180-86.

Kaushik, Sandeep 1996. “Resistance, Loyalty and Recusant Politics: Sir Thomas Tresham and the Elizabethan State.” Midland History 21: 37-72.

Knox, T. F. 1882. Letters and Memorials of Cardinal Allen (1532-1594). London: David Nutt.

Law, T. G. 1904 (1893). “The Spanish Blanks and the Catholic Earls, 1592-1594.” Ed. P. Hume Brown. Collected Essays and Reviews of Thomas Graves Law, LL.D. Edinburgh: T. & A. Constable: 244-72.

Lecey, John 1604. A petition apologeticall > see Tresham, Thomas (1604).

Lee, Maurice, Jr. 1970. James I and Henri IV: An Essay in English Foreign Policy, 1603-1610. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.

Lemon, R. and M. A. E. Green, eds. 1856-1872. Calendar of State Papers, Domestic Series, of the Reigns of Edward VI, Mary, Elizabeth [and James I] 1574-1625. 12 vols. London: HM Stationery Office.

Lennon, Colm 1980. Richard Stanihurst: The Dubliner, 1547-1618. Dublin: Irish Academic Press.

Lethbridge, Charles, William Arthur Shaw and Geraint Dyfnallt Owen, eds. 1925-1966. Report on the Manuscripts of Lord de L’Isle & Dudley: preserved at Penshurst Place. Royal Commission on Historical Manuscripts. 6 vols. London: HM Stationery Office.

Lomas, S. C., ed. 1904. The Manuscripts of T. B. Clarke-Thornhill, Esq., Sir T. Barrett-Lennard, Bart., Pelham R. Papillon, Esq., and W. Cleverly Alexander, Esq. Report on Manuscripts in Various Collections 3. Royal Commission on Historical Manuscripts. London: HM Stationery Office, 1904.

Loomie, Albert J. 1963a. The Spanish Elizabethans: The English Exiles at the Court of Philip II. New York: Fordham University Press.

Loomie, Albert J.  1963b. “Toleration and Diplomacy: The Religious Issue in Anglo-Spanish Relations, 1603-1605.” Transactions of the American Philosophical Society, n.s. 53.6: 1-52.

Loomie, Albert J.  1963-1964. “A Catholic Petition to the Earl of Essex.” Recusant History 7: 33-42.

Loomie, Albert J.  1965. “Philip III and the Stuart succession in England, 1600-1603.” Revue belge de Philologie et d’Histoire 43: 492-514.

Loomie, Albert J.  1973. Spain and the Jacobean Catholics. Vol I: 1603-1612. Publications of the Catholic Record Society 64. London: Catholic Record Society.

Lovell, Mary S. 2005. Bess of Hardwick: First Lady of Chatsworth. London: Little, Brown.

Manning, Roger B. 1969. Religion and Society in Elizabethan Sussex: A study of the enforcement of the religious settlement, 1558-1603. Leicester: Leicester University Press.

Martin, A. Lynn 1973. Henry III and the Jesuit Politicians. Geneva: Droz.

Martin, Patrick and John Finnis 2002-2003. “The Identity of ‘Antony Rivers’.” Recusant History 26: 39-74.

McCann, Justin 1952. Ampleforth and its Origins: Essays on a Living Tradition. London: Burns Oates and Washbourne.

McClure, N. E., ed. 1939. Letters of John Chamberlain. 2 vols. Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society.

McCoog, Thomas M. 2004. “Harmony Disrupted: Robert Parsons, S.J., William Crichton, S.J. and the Question of Queen Elizabeth’s Successor, 1581-1603.” Archivum Historicum Societatis Iesu 73: 149-220.

Medina, Francisco de Borja 1996. “Intrigues of a Scottish Jesuit at the Spanish Court: Unpublished Letters of William Crichton to Claudio Acquaviva (Madrid 1590-1592).” Ed. Thomas M. McCoog, The Reckoned Expense: Edmund Campion and the Early English Jesuits. Woodbridge, Suffolk: The Boydell Press: 215-45.

Mornay, Philippe de 1598. De l’Institution, usage, et doctrine du Sainct Sacrement de l’Eucharistie, en l’Église ancienne. Ensemble; Comment, quand, & par quels degrez la Messe s’est introduite en sa place. 2nd edition. La Rochelle.

Mornay, Philippe de 1600a. Fowre Bookes, of the Institution, Use and Doctrine of the Holy Sacrament of the Eucharist in the old Church. As likewise how […] the Masse is brought in, in place thereof. Trans. R. S. London: J. Windet for I. B., T. M., and W. P.

Mornay, Philippe de 1600b. Discours véritable de la conférence tenue à Fontainebleau le quatriesme de may 1600, entre le sieur du Plessis at l’Évesque d’Évreux. Paris.

Mornay, Philippe de 1600c. A Discourse of the Conference holden before the French King at Fontain-bleau, betwene the L. Bishop of Eureux, and Munsieur Plessis L. of Mornay, the 4 of May 1600. Concerning certaine pretended corruptions of Authours, cyted by the sayd Munsier du Plessis in his booke against the Masse. London: E.A. for Mathew Selman and William Ferbrand.

Patterson, W. B. 1997. King James VI and I and the Reunion of Christendom. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Peck, Francis 1779. Desiderata Curiosa: Or, A Collection of Divers Scarce and Curious Pieces Relating Chiefly to Matters of English History. Revised edition. 2 vols. London: Thomas Evans.

Peck, L. L. 1982. Northampton: Patronage and Policy at the Court of James I. London: George Allen and Unwin.

Persons, Robert 1595. (R. Doleman, pseud.) A Conference about the Next Succession to the Crowne of Ingland. Antwerp: Arnout Conincx.

Persons, Robert 1604. The Third Part of a Treatise, Intituled: of three Conversions of England: conteyning. An Examen of the Calendar or Catalogue of Protestant Saints, Martyrs and Confessors, divised by John Fox […] The first six monethes. Wherunto in the end is annexed a defence of a certaine Triall, made before the King of France upon the yeare 1600. betweene Monsieur Peron Bishop of Evreux, and Monsieur Plessis Mornay Governour of Saumur, about sundry points of Religion. A Treatise of Three Conversions 2. St Omer: François Bellet.

Persons, Robert 1690. The Jesuit’s Memorial, for the Intended Reformation of England Under their First Popish Prince. Ed. Edward Gee. London: Richard Chiswel.

Pollen, J. H. 1903. “The Accession of King James I.” The Month 101: 572-85.

Pollen, J. H. 1920. The English Catholics in the Reign of Queen Elizabeth: A Study of their Politics, Civil Life and Government. 1558-1580: From the Fall of the Old Church to the Advent of the Counter-Reformation. London: Longmans, Green and Co.

Pollen, J. H.  ed. 1906. “Memoirs of Father Robert Persons.” CRS Miscellanea II. Publications of the Catholic Record Society 2. London: Catholic Record Society: 12-218.

Questier, Michael C. 2005. “Elizabeth and the Catholics.” Ed. Ethan Shagan. Catholics and the “Protestant nation.” Manchester: Manchester University Press: 69-94.

Questier, Michael C. 2006. Catholicism and Community in Early Modern England: Politics, Aristocratic Patronage, and Religion, c. 1550-1640. Cambridge: Cambridge UP.

Roberts, Richard Arthur, Edward Salisbury, Montague Guiseppi and Geraint Dyfnallt Owen, eds. 1883-1976. Calendar of the Manuscripts of the Most Hon. the Marquis of Salisbury, K.G., &c. […] preserved at Hatfield House, Hertfordshire. Royal Commission on Historical Manuscripts. 24 vols. London: HM Stationery Office.

Rogers, David 1959-1960. “The Catholic Moderator: A French Reply to Bellarmine and its English Author, Henry Constable.” Recusant History 5: 224-35.

Sena, Margaret 2000. “William Blundell and the networks of Catholic dissent in post-Reformation England.” Eds. Alexandra Shepard and Phil Withington. Communities in Early Modern England: Networks, Place, Rhetoric. Manchester and New York: Manchester University Press: 54-75.

Stafford, H. G. 1940. James VI of Scotland and the Throne of England. American Historical Association. New York and London: Appleton-Century.

Stroud, Theodore A. 1951. “Father Thomas Wright: A Test Case for Toleration.” Biographical Studies 1: 189-219.

Sutton, Dana F. 1997. Introduction. Unpublished Works by William Alabaster. Salzburg: University of Salzburg.

Tresham, Thomas 1604. (John Lecey, pseud.) A petition apologeticall, presented to the Kinges most excellent Maiesty, by the lay Catholikes of England, in Iuly last. Douai: Iohn Mogar, at the signe of the Compas, vere English secret press, connected with William Wrench.

Tutino, Stefania 2009. “The Political Thought of Robert Persons’s Conference in Continental Context.” The Historical Journal 52: 43-62.

Walsham, Alexandra 2000. “‘Yielding to the Extremity of the Time’: Conformity, Orthodoxy and the Post-Reformation Catholic Community.” Eds. Peter Lake and Michael Questier. Conformity and Orthodoxy in the English Church, c. 1560-1660. Woodbridge, Suffolk: The Boydell Press: 211-36.

Watson, William 1602. A Decacordon of Ten Quodlibeticall Questions concerning Religion and State. London: Richard Field.

Wickes, George 1953-1954. “Henry Constable, Poet and Courtier (1562-1613).” Biographical Studies 2: 272-300.