Sederi 26 — 2016
Francisco J. Borge López
María José Mora
Susana Oliveira, “‘The intolerable business’: Religion and diplomacy under Elizabeth’s rule.” SEDERI 26 (2016): 159–174.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.34136/sederi.2016.7 Download PDF
Within the scope of foreign affairs between Portugal and England during Elizabeth’s rule, numerous events indicate the challenges faced by the Portuguese ambassadors on their missions. Regrettably, little is known about these envoys and one rarely finds any reference to their names or their diplomatic accomplishments in Early Modern studies. This paper focuses on a diplomatic incident which involved Francisco Giraldes, a Portuguese resident ambassador in England, aiming to shed some light on “the intolerable business” that led to a confrontation with the Bishop of London, Edwin Sandys. Attending a Catholic Mass in the context of the Elizabethan Religious Settlement involved certain challenges that should be considered. Diplomats, however, enjoyed certain immunities, including the droit de chappelle, and were allowed to hold Catholic services in their ambassadorial residences. But in March 1573, while Mass was being held, Francisco Giraldes’s residence was raided by the Sheriff of London’s men, working under the Bishop of London’s instructions. The ongoing tension between the religious and the political areas of power was, thus, exposed. Two letters, written by the Bishop of London, included in the Lansdowne Manuscripts Collection of the British Library, registered the event. As Sandy’s correspondence appears to be the single piece of surviving evidence regarding this diplomatic incident, it stands to reason that its analysis will provide significant insight into the coexistence, as well as the clash, of oppositional forces, while further contributing to an interpretation of Anglo-Portuguese affairs in Early Modern times.
Keywords: Early Modern; diplomacy; religion; Anglo-Portuguese relations.
Aughterson, Kate, ed. 1998. “Papal Bull.” In The English Renaissance: An Anthology of Sources and Documents, 36–37. London and New York: Routledge.
Bacon, Nicholas. 1682 (1559). “The Journal of the House of the Lords: Proceedings in the House of the Lords, in the Parliament holden at Westminster Aº Iº Regin. Eliz. A. D. 1558 & 1559.” In The Journals of All the Parliaments During the Reign of Queen Elizabeth both of The House of Lords and House of Commons, edited by Paul Bowes, 31–35. London: John Starkey.
Barber, Peter. 1979. Diplomacy: The World of the Honest Spy. London: Longwood.
Barker, Craig J. 2006. The Protection of Diplomatic Personnel. Hampshire and Burlington: Ashgate Publishing.
Birth, Henry Norbert. 1907. The Elizabethan Religious Settlement: A Study of Contemporary Documents. London: George Bell.
Black, Jeremy. 2010. A History of Diplomacy. London: Reaktion Books.
Brady, Thomas A. et al, eds. 1994. Handbook of European History 1400– 1600: Late Middle Ages, Renaissance and Reformation. Leiden, New York: Brill.
Bullein, William. 1888. A Dialogue against the Feuer Pestilence. Edited by Mark W. Bullen and A. H. Bullen. London: Early English Text Society by E. Trübner.
Butler, Geoffrey, and Simon Maccoby 2003 (1928). The Development of International Law. New Jersey: The Lawbook Exchange.
De Callières, François. 1716. De la manière de négocier avec les Souverains: de l’utilité des négociations, du choix des ambassadeurs et des envoyez, et des qualitez necessaires pour réussir dans ces emplois. Amsterdam: pour la Compagnie.
Elizabeth I. 1806 (1585). “The Queen’s Speech at Proroguing the Parliament.” In The Parliamentary History of England, from the Earliest Period to the Year 1803, edited by William Cobbett, Vol. 1, 833–34. London: T.C. Hansard, Peterborough-Court.
“Elizabeth: January 1578, 21–31.” 1901. In Calendar of State Papers Foreign, Elizabeth, Volume 12, 1577–78, edited by Arthur John Butler, 464–82. London: Her Majesty’s Stationery Office.
Eliot, T.S. 1975 (1939). “The Idea of a Christian Society.” In Selected Prose of T. S. Eliot, edited by Frank Kermode, 285–291. London and Boston: Faber and Faber.
Embaixada e Governo de D. Duarte Castelo Branco 1571-1581 Vol. IV. Manuscritos da Biblioteca da Ajuda, Palácio Nacional da Ajuda. Fols. 123-125.
Grindal, Edmund. 1843. The Remains of Edmund Grindal, D.D.: Successively Bishop of London and Archbishop of York and Canterbury. Edited by Rev. William Nicholson. Cambridge: University Press.
Hampton, Timothy. 2009. Fictions of Embassy: Literature and Diplomacy in Early Modern Europe. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press.
Hume, Martin A. S. ed. 1892-1899. Calendar of Letters and State Papers relating to English Affairs preserved principally in the Archive of Simancas. London: Eyre and Spottiswoode.
Lansdowne Manuscripts. “Edwyn, Bp. of Worcester, to Sir Wm Cecil; his grief that his refusing the Archbishopric of London has displeased him, &c. April 26, 1570.” MS British Library, Lansdowne 12. fol. 82.
Lansdowne Manuscripts. “Edwyn, Bp. of London, to the Lord Treasurer; concerning the Portuguese Ambassador’s undue encouragement of the Mass. March 2, 1573.” MS British Library, Lansdowne 16. fol. 25.
Lansdowne Manuscripts. “Edwyn, Bp. of London, to the Earl of Leicester; he warmly pleads against tolerating the Portuguese Ambassador to hear Mass, and calls him a calf-worshipper. March 4, 1573.” MS British Library, Lansdowne 16. fol. 26.
Mattingly, Garrett. 1955. Renaissance Diplomacy. Middlesex and Victoria: Penguin.
McClanahan, Grant V. 1989. Diplomatic Immunity: Principles, Practices, Problems. London and Washington DC: C. Hurst & Co. Publishers.
Mortimer, Ian. 2013. The Time Traveller’s Guide to Elizabethan England. London: Bodley Head.
Patterson, Annabel. 2004. Reading between the Lines. London: Routledge.
Rabb, Theodore. 1998. Jacobean Gentleman: Sir Edwin Sandys, 1561–1629. Princeton and West Sussex: Princeton University Press.
Sandys, Edwin. 1841. The Sermons of Edwin Sandys, D. D., Successively Bishop of Worcester and London and Archbishop of York: To Which Are Added Some Miscellaneous Pieces by the Same Author. Edited by John Ayre. Cambridge: Printed at the University Press.
Santarém, Manuel Francisco de Barros e Sousa, Visconde de, ed. 1865. Quadro elementar das relações politicas e diplomaticas de Portugal: com as diversas potencias do mundo, desde o principio da monarchia portugueza até aos nossos dias. Vol. 15. Lisboa: Academia Real das Ciências.
The Holy Bible. 2003 (1611). Authorized King James Version. NP: Thomas Nelson, Inc.
Wagner, John A. 2010. Voices of Shakespeare´s England; Contemporary Accounts of Elizabethan Daily Life. Santa Barbara: Greenwood.
Watkins, John. 2008. “Toward a New Diplomatic History of Medieval and Early Modern Europe.” Journal of Medieval and Early Modern Studies 38 (1): 1–14.
Wicquefort, Abraham de. 1689. L’Ambassadeur et ses Fonctions. Vol. 2. Cologne: chez Pierre Marteau.
Wright, Thomas. 1838. Queen Elizabeth and her Times: a Series of Original Letters, Selected from the Inedited Private Correspondence of the Lord Treasurer Burghley, the Earl of Leicester, the Secretaries Walsingham and Smith, Sir Christopher Hatton, and Most of the Distinguished Persons of the Period. Vol. I. London: Henry Colburn.